On a typical day in North Dakota prairie towns like Williston, Dickinson and Beulah, trains with 100 tank cars line up to be loaded with oil destined for markets to the east, west, and south.

In total, about 675,000 barrels of crude leave daily on as many as 10 trains from North Dakota, now the second largest oil-producing state after Texas. That’s due to the drilling process known as hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, that has rendered accessible petroleum once too costly to procure.

The accident in Lac-Megantic, Quebec, where authorities are investigating how the unattended train managed to roll into town and incinerate 30 buildings, has added urgency to the debate over the safety of rail versus pipelines -- a debate in which both industries offer statistics suggesting an advantage. Photographer: Surete du Quebec/The Canadian Press via AP Photo

Railroad tracks stand in Underwood, North Dakota. In the 10 years ending in 2012, U.S. railroads suffered 129 spill incidents while hauling 11.2 billion gallons of crude, according to the Association of American Railroads. Photographer: Daniel Acker/Bloomberg

A U.S. Department of Transportation placard used to identify tankers transporting denatured alcohol, or ethanol, is displayed on a rail car in Underwood, North Dakota. Photographer: Daniel Acker/Bloomberg

Production in the state is rising so fast -- from about 150,000 barrels a day in 2008 to more than 790,000 today -- that pipeline construction can’t keep up. Railroads move 75 percent of its oil, including the load of more than 70 tanker cars that derailed and exploded July 6 in a small Canadian town, killing at least 15 and leaving dozens missing.

“The oil development has happened so rapidly, it’s ahead of the infrastructure to deal with it,” said Wayde Schafer, an organizer for the North Dakota chapter of the Sierra Club, a San Francisco environmental group that wants to decrease use of fossil fuels.

Lines now cross population centers and sensitive wildlife habitats, he said. “The railroads didn’t have transporting oil in mind when they laid out the routes,” Schafer said.

The accident in Lac-Megantic, Quebec, where authorities are investigating how the unattended train managed to roll into town and incinerate 30 buildings, has added urgency to the debate over the safety of rail versus pipelines -- a debate in which both industries offer statistics suggesting an advantage.

More MishapsIn general, railroads tend to have more mishaps though the amount of oil spilled is greater from pipelines.

Oil-trade groups say all modes of transportation are safe.

“Over 99.9 percent of deliveries make it to the end user without incident,” Cindy Schild, senior manager for refining and oil sands for the American Petroleum Institute, whose members include Exxon Mobil Corp. (XOM) in Irving, Texas, said yesterday in a conference call with reporters.

A boom in North American oil production has helped drive a flurry of proposals to build or expand pipelines, includingTransCanada Corp. (TRP)’s proposed Keystone XL, now under review by the U.S. State Department. Keystone would move mostly crude from Alberta’s oil sands to refineries on the U.S. Gulf of Mexico, though it would also be fed oil from North Dakota.

The Montreal Maine & Atlantic Railway Ltd. train that crashed in Lac-Megantic was hauling crude from North Dakota to Irving Oil Corp.’s 298,800-barrel-a-day Saint John refinery in New Brunswick. The carrier is owned by the closely held Rail World Inc. of Chicago.

Railroad IncidentsThe amount of oil hauled by rail in the U.S. rose more than 2,000 percent from 2009 to 2012, when 6.5 billion gallons were carried on trains.

In the 10 years ending in 2012, U.S. railroads suffered 129 spill incidents while hauling 11.2 billion gallons of crude, according to the Association of American Railroads, whose members include BNSF Railways Company, a major carrier in North Dakota and subsidiary of Berkshire Hathaway Inc. (BRK/A)

Over that period, 95,256 gallons spilled from railroads, with one accident in Oklahoma in 2008 accounting for 81,103 gallons. More typically, the releases occurred during loading or unloading in a rail yard, according to Holly Arthur, a spokeswoman for the Washington-based group.

While the frequency of spills from railroads is higher than for pipelines, pipeline spills are typically four times larger, Arthur said.

Spill RatePipelines carried 13.6 billion barrels (571.2 billion gallons) of crude and petroleum products in 2012 and reported 54,023 barrels released, according to John Stoody, spokesman for the Association of Oil Pipe Lines. Over the past 10 years, the number of leaks has fallen 60 percent while the amounts released have fallen 43 percent.

In the 20 years ending in 2012, there were 364 spills involving pipelines carrying oil, petroleum products and other hazardous liquids, according to the U.S. Department of Transportation. Over that period there have been 39 fatalities and 137 injuries at pipelines, mostly involving pipeline workers.

Andrew Leach, an energy and environmental economist at the University of Alberta, said that while spills from pipelines are likely to be larger, there is a greater likelihood that a rail accident would occur in more populated areas, potentially causing more injuries and property losses. Accidents such as the one in Quebec hurt the image of both industries, he said.

“This is just another reason the public is going to say, ‘I don’t want this near me,’” Leach said in an interview.

Keystone XLKeystone, which is opposed by groups including the Sierra Club and Natural Resources Defense Council because they say it exacerbates the risk of climate change by promoting development of the oil sands, has also sparked a debate over the relative safety of rail versus pipeline to transport oil.

“To frame Keystone XL as something that can save us from oil on rail, it isn’t,” Anthony Swift, an energy analyst for the Natural Resources Defense Council in Washington, said in a telephone interview. “This demonstrates the risks associated with moving crude oil across all modes of transportation.”

In 2009, North Dakota was shipping about 20,000 barrels of oil a day along its rail lines. Four years later, the total had increased by more than 3,000 percent, according to Justin Kringstad, director of the North Dakota Pipeline Authority.

‘New Challenges’The rapid rise in oil and gas production presents, “new challenges for the entire transportation system,” said Brigham McCown, a former director of the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration, a division within the U.S. Transportation Department that regulates the transport of oil and other dangerous products.

McCown, now a transportation consultant, said rail transport is safe. He supports construction of the Keystone pipeline as another alternative for shipping oil, noting that rail lines pass through more populated centers.

An early focus of the inquiry into the deadly derailment in Quebec is on the risks of a rail car widely used in both the U.S. and Canada. Officials from the National Transportation Safety Board in 2012 recommended that the U.S. Transportation Department require rail companies to retrofit the cars, known as DOT-111s, to make leaks and fires less likely.

The Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration is reviewing the recommendations, which are opposed by the Association of American Railroads. The group says the risks don’t justify the costs of the upgrades.

Environmental groups said the Quebec accident shows the need to reduce reliance on fossil fuels in general.

“It’s a false choice to choose between rail and pipelines,” Kate Colarulli, deputy director of the Sierra Club’s “Beyond Oil” campaign, said in an interview. “Communities are going to have to live under this threat of accidents until we reduce the oil we use.”

To contact the reporters on this story: Jim Snyder in Washington at jsnyder24@bloomberg.net; Jim Efstathiou Jr. in New York at jefstathiou@bloomberg.net



01/29/2016 10:26pm

Wonderful post!!! Genuinely loved this kind of post. Although I want much more information on like precious subject matter. 

05/11/2016 4:56am

Transport risk in delivering oil in North Dakota is serious matter, because oil consumption increasing day by day and shipment of oils should be fast to meet current consumption.Government should take some positive steps to improve it.

05/11/2016 8:57am

Many people want to have the ability to choose how their electricity is generated; environmentally friendly or not. To answer that question and to reduce the emission of harmful gases, is a system set up in the Netherlands, making environmentally friendly electricity can be sold as a separate product.Nice article you have shared. For any assistance please visit gaslicht.com

06/10/2016 2:16am

Transportation of oil in any way is risk only. BY, train or pipeline anything risk is involved in that. This overcome only by taking perfect safety measures in transportation the oil by using safe channel and not get into residential areas. After Accident happen or incident occur than only this kind of debate starts till than every official will sleep without thinking about anything.


Obviously these ten tips indicates good and responsible shipping companies, If a company contain these qualities it will be best shipping company in particular servicing area.

07/04/2016 11:59pm

Oil is important energy source for our life, oil can lighten up anything it can lighten up electricity , car or anything else. but this source is limited for use because in a years oil increasingly reduced. beside use oil we can use alternative energy such as solar , wind or anything so we can save our fossil energy for our child. if you want to know more about saving energy you can visit our site wechseljetzt.de.

08/28/2016 5:33am

In case you are moving to Dallas know that buying real estate over renting makes better financial sense. Purchasing Dallas real estate is the best move you can make financially because if you are leasing a home or a condo then your monthly lease payments are going directly to the landlord's pocket with no return for you in it.


Thank you for useful information. It is exactly what I needed. I managed to get here everything that I need for my article.


The post is absolutely fantastic.

11/12/2016 2:47pm

A limousine is a luxury sedan or saloon car that is made of a lengthened base wheel and driven by a chauffeur. These are also commonly called stretch limousines and they traditionally come in black and white colors. Limousines are most commonly linked with affluent people, because they are costly to purchase.

12/07/2016 10:44am

Wow! what an idea ! What a concept ! Beautiful .. Amazing

12/17/2016 9:57pm

compared to other western countries public transport. You can also choose what kind of public transport you want to avail, it depends upon your choice

12/24/2016 12:09am

Interesting discussion about transportation, and everyone having really nice discussion on it, yeah that's true there are lot's of companies, are providing best transportation, services in there area's.

12/24/2016 6:44am

I actually do have great advice on what to wear while traveling to make your experience comfy, convenient, and always cute.

01/02/2017 9:25am

Your article is really an inspiration to many.

01/27/2017 11:05am

For sure in renting a Miami limousine service, one wanted to have a smooth plan on that special occasion, which maybe a wedding, prom, trip with your loved ones and the like. On such occasion, you definitely do not want anything to go wrong, so amidst of all the other works and plans you're doing, the transportation is also one factor you should give time as well.

02/06/2017 6:01pm

Nice Post !! I like it, it also comprises a lot of useful facts. thanks to share your experience.

02/10/2017 4:17am

Wow! I am mainly surprised by the way you unique out almost every single little detail. It can be genuinely heading to aid me a great offer. Thanks for sharing your suggestions so certainly.

02/28/2017 11:51am

Gallo Brothers Development Inc a Norristown REIT that buys and develops office buildings and mixed-use developments in major East Coast markets. The company initially focused on Montgomery, bucks, Delaware, and Philadelphia counties.


Awesome post! Really enjoyed this post. But I want more information on such valuable topic.

03/26/2017 4:25pm

Looking for a motorcycle helmet? Motorcycle helmet review looks at the different types of motorcycle helmets.

04/05/2017 3:37pm

RTL offers customized flexible services for all your requirements. Warehousing Toronto facilities, Distribution Services in Toronto & Order Fulfillment, Inventory Management, Cross Docking, North American LTL & TL transportation, Small parcel service, when required, Cross Border Transportation, Consolidation and de-consolidation, Intermodal and Containers Delivery service, Daily transportation Canada and US Local Cartage, Reverse Logistics.

04/26/2017 4:57am

Frontline Logistics is a leading provider of Less-Than-Truckload (LTL) service in North America.


It is exactly what I needed. I managed to get here everything

06/15/2017 2:25am

A car seat canopy makes a great gift at a baby shower. It is the perfect way to protect your little newborn when you are out of the house.

08/29/2017 12:54pm

Yeah, that's true these ten tips indicates nice and accountable shipping businesses, If a business comprise these qualities it is going to be best shipping firm particularly servicing region.

08/30/2017 6:31am

RV Dealers - New and Used RVs For Sale by Dealer. Find Fifth Wheel, Class A, Class B, and Class C RVs from RV Dealers near you.

08/31/2017 7:03am

If you would like it securely delivered to you personally, you'll need to obtain a trusted and affordable transport business which has a automobile transport package which fits your requirements and your budget.

09/01/2017 8:42am

Well, If you'd like it firmly delivered to you personally, you'll want to acquire a trusted and inexpensive transport business that has a automobile transport package which matches your needs and your budget.


Thanks great job for publishing such a beneficial web site. Your web log isn’t only useful but it is additionally really creative.

10/10/2017 10:33am

The costs of limousine rental services actually vary on a number of factors. The time of the year at which you are going to rent it may affect the price. You can expect peak seasons to have higher rates for limo prices and you can anticipate for much lower costs during the non-peak days. The type of limousine may also vary the costs of your rental. If you are about to rent a brand new limousine, you can only expect for much higher prices. The better the quality, the higher the price of the limousine.


Airport limo services are designed to help provide travelers with quick and simple, and sometimes elegant transportation to and also from airports. Different services range in price and can also include valet parking of the traveler's own vehicle as well as transportation to other locations as well as airports. Using these services can take the headache out of traveling and save gas as well as wear and tear on the traveler's vehicle.


Leave a Reply

SPYDR Oilfield Service LLC. Copyright 2013 - 513 East Broadway, Williston, North Dakota 58801 701-774-2340 SPYDR OILFIELD SERVICE -Roustabout -Oil Field Contstruction- Oilfield Maintenance